How Did I End Up Here? Navigating the Mystery of Unexplained Meetings
We've all been there. You're sitting in a conference room (or these days, staring at a grid of faces on Zoom), and the sudden thought hits you like a freight train: *Why am I here?* Not in an existential crisis kind of way, but in a genuine moment of professional confusion where you cannot, for the life of you, figure out how or why you ended up in this particular meeting.
The Anatomy of Meeting Confusion
It usually starts innocently enough. Perhaps it was that calendar invite you absentmindedly accepted three weeks ago while triaging your inbox between calls. Or maybe your name was added to a recurring series that began with a clear purpose but has since morphed into something unrecognizable. Whatever the origin story, the result is the same – you're now 15 minutes into a discussion about quarterly projections for a product line you've never worked on, trying desperately to piece together why anyone thought your presence was necessary.
I recently found myself in this exact scenario. As the discussion bounced around the virtual room, I frantically scrolled through emails, searching for any clue that might explain my inclusion. Was I supposed to present something? Was I filling in for someone on my team? Had I missed a crucial pre-meeting where context would have been provided? The meeting agenda (if there ever was one) offered no clues.
The Five Stages of Meeting Confusion
If you've experienced this workplace phenomenon, you might recognize these distinct emotional phases:
Denial
"I must know why I'm here. I wouldn't be in this meeting without reason. Let me just listen a bit longer and it will all make sense..."
Self-Doubt
"Did I miss something important? Am I supposed to know what 'Project Falcon' is? Should I have prepared something?"
Anxiety
"Everyone seems to understand what's happening. If I speak up now, I'll look completely incompetent. Better stay quiet and nod occasionally."
Resignation
"Well, I guess this is my life now. I live in this meeting. I'll never know why I'm here, but I've committed too much time to leave."
Subtle Investigation
"Maybe if I ask this very carefully worded question, I can both contribute something meaningful AND figure out what this meeting is actually about..."
The Silent Epidemic
What's particularly fascinating is how common this experience is, yet how rarely we discuss it. In an anonymous survey I conducted among my professional network, a staggering 76% of respondents admitted to finding themselves in at least one meeting per month where they had no clear understanding of why they were included or what value they were supposed to provide.
The problem has only intensified in our remote working world. Calendar invites fly back and forth with reckless abandon. Meeting series propagate and mutate. People get added "just to keep them in the loop" or "in case they have input." Before you know it, your day is a patchwork quilt of meetings where your role ranges from "essential contributor" to "completely bewildered observer."
The Real Costs
While it might seem like a harmless workplace quirk, these mystery meetings come with real costs:
Time waste: The average professional spends approximately 31 hours per month in meetings, and studies suggest that roughly 30% of that time is unproductive. That's nearly a full workday each month spent in confusion.
Cognitive drain: The mental energy expended trying to figure out why you're in a meeting and what you're supposed to contribute could be directed toward actual productive work.
Decreased morale: Few things are more demoralising than feeling like you're wasting your time or that your presence is so inconsequential that no one bothered to explain why you're needed.
Meeting fatigue: Every unnecessary meeting contributes to the overall meeting fatigue that plagues modern workplaces, making us less effective even in the important gatherings.
Escape Routes and Prevention Strategies
So what can we do, both to extract ourselves from these situations and prevent them in the future?
When You're Already in Mystery Meeting Territory
The direct approach: Sometimes honesty is the best policy. A simple, "I'm sorry, but I'm not sure I understand my role in this discussion. Could someone clarify why I was included?" can work wonders. Most people will appreciate the clarity rather than having a disengaged participant.
The strategic message: If speaking up feels too uncomfortable, a private message to the meeting organiser can work: "Hi Sam, I want to make sure I'm contributing effectively to this discussion. Could you help me understand what perspective you'd like me to bring to this conversation?"
The graceful exit: If it becomes clear your presence truly isn't necessary, it's perfectly acceptable to say, "It seems like this discussion doesn't require my input at this stage. Unless anyone objects, I'll excuse myself and catch up through the meeting notes."
Preventing Future Meeting Mysteries
Question before accepting: Make it a habit to reply to ambiguous meeting invites with a quick, "Could you share the agenda and let me know what you'd like me to contribute to this discussion?"
Set expectations: Establish a personal policy that you don't attend meetings without a clear purpose and communicate this boundary respectfully to your colleagues.
Regular calendar audits: Schedule time monthly to review recurring meetings and evaluate whether your continued presence is necessary or valuable.
Be part of the solution: When organising meetings yourself, be explicit about why each participant is included and what you expect from them.
The Cultural Shift We Need
Beyond individual strategies, we need a broader cultural shift in how we approach meetings. Organizations that reduce meeting overload report higher productivity, improved employee satisfaction, and better work-life balance.
Some progressive companies have implemented:
Meeting-free days each week
Required agendas for all meetings over 15 minutes
"Role and goal" requirements where each participant's purpose must be defined
Regular "meeting purges" where all recurring meetings are canceled and only those that prove necessary are reestablished
Finding the Humour in the Absurdity
While working to improve meeting culture is important, finding humor in these moments of workplace absurdity can be equally valuable. There's something universally comical about a room full of professionals, all pretending they know exactly why they're there, while secretly harboring the same confusion.
I've started keeping a "mystery meeting journal" where I document the most bewildering gatherings I've found myself in. My personal favorite was a 90-minute session discussing the technical specifications for a product that, as I discovered 45 minutes in, had actually been discontinued two months earlier. Apparently, no one had thought to cancel the recurring meeting series.
The Silver Lining
Strangely enough, these moments of professional confusion can lead to unexpected benefits. I've made valuable connections with colleagues who were equally confused and formed bonds over our shared bewilderment. I've learned about projects and initiatives I wouldn't otherwise have been exposed to. And most importantly, these experiences have taught me to be more intentional about how I spend my time and how I communicate purpose to others.
So the next time you find yourself staring blankly at a presentation about something completely disconnected from your work, take comfort in knowing you're not alone in your confusion. We're all occasionally lost in the labyrinth of modern workplace communication, trying to figure out how we ended up here.
And sometimes, the most productive thing you can do is simply ask.
---
Have you ever found yourself completely confused about why you were included in a meeting? Share your experience in the comments below, and let us know how you handled it!